Season Four: GOOD or BAD

[coalescent]

To be clear: I have not watched "Journey's End" yet, because bibliolicious is out at a gig this evening. But I wouldn't wish to deprive anyone of poll-clicking fun, and anyway I'm planning to pretty much avoid the internet for the next 24 hours, so:

[Poll #1218259]

Feel free to link to your Who posts in the comments. Actually, that would be really helpful, because by the time I get around to watching the episode any relevant posts will probably be buried at about skip=300, and thus difficult to find.

Comments

[iainjclark.livejournal.com]

I've voted S3 as the best because even though I do think S4 was stronger on average, you can't argue with Blink, Human Nature and The Family of Blood.

My finale review be here. EDIT: And my season overview is here.

[mokatiki.livejournal.com]

Well looks like I only saw 6 of 13, and I haven't seen Journeys End yet either (although I am planning to see it before we see you tomorrow, or I fear I will not be able to talk to anyone!).

I also voted to 4 because this is the most Dr Who I've actually watched. Wonder whose influence that is.

[surliminal.livejournal.com]

Tough - now you mention it 3 was pretty good but I did love the freshness of the Ecleston series and Jack, gas masks, first love, Dalek -- oh yes.

I did a review..

[frogworth.livejournal.com]

I voted GOOD for every episode. This is weird, because I do think quite a few weren't that great, but somehow didn't think they were "BAD".
I also voted for Season 1 as best, because it *was* fresh and fun - but of course with Blink, Human Nature and The Family of Blood, Season 3 does do pretty well :)

Just wanted to say

[(Anonymous)]

Thank you

Brilliant page.

[(Anonymous)]

Cognitive post.., man

thank you

[(Anonymous)]

thats for sure, guy